Your cards deserve the Trophy Club.
We consign your cards on Fanatics Collect — sports, Pokémon, One Piece, and every grail in between. Best rates in the hobby, above-market hammers, and a real expert in your corner on when to sell, hold, or regrade.
Graded, raw, or sealed — we consign it all.
Raw cards graded on the way up · sealed product welcome · backed by the Fanatics Collect vault
*Your payout is a share of the total sale price — the winning bid plus Fanatics' 20% buyer's premium. Published rates scale from 85% up to 95%. Full breakdown in the rate table below.
Flagship monthly auctions — where the grails get max eyes and top hammers.
Fast, steady turnover for mid-market cards — sold every week.
What's live right now
Real client cards we placed — live and taking bids. Yours could be next.
Keep more of every sale.
The bigger the card, the bigger your share — you keep up to 95% of the total sale price. Simple, published rates. No hidden fees, no negotiation.
*Your payout is the percentage of the total sale price — the winning bid plus Fanatics' 20% buyer's premium — that lands in your pocket. Lots under $150 are paid at 85% minus a $5 handling fee. No hidden fees, no negotiation.
A real expert who tells you straight.
The big consigners treat you like a tracking number. We don't. Before a single card goes live, we give you a personal, honest read on every card — backed by real comp data and years in the hobby.
- Sell now, or hold for a hotter window? We'll tell you.
- Worth a regrade or crossover first? We'll do the math.
- Premier, weekly, or buy-now? We place it where it pops.
Four steps. Zero friction.
From the first message to the final wire — we handle the entire pipeline.
Submit your cards
Tell us what you have through a simple form — photos, grades, what you're hoping to get. 60 seconds.
Ship to our vault
We send insured shipping instructions. Your cards arrive safe and go straight into the Fanatics Collect vault.
We list & sell
Pro photography, strategic timing, the right auction. We handle every buyer message and push for above-market.
Get paid
Hammer lands, payment clears, we wire you directly — usually same week. Track every dollar in real time.
Max value, or instant cash.
Want top dollar at auction, or money in hand today? Your call — we do both.
Consign at auction
Let us place your card in the right Fanatics Collect auction and pull the highest hammer the market will give.
- Highest possible sale price
- Real-time tracking + expert strategy
- Best consignment rate in the hobby
Sell to us today
Need liquidity now? Send a photo and your number — we accept, counter, or decline fast and pay quick.
- Cash in hand, no waiting on auction
- Fair offers based on real comps
- Deal done in minutes
Built by collectors, for collectors.
No faceless portal. Two long-time dealers with direct lines to the Fanatics auction team — real names, real phone numbers, real accountability.
Sean
Years deep in the hobby and the dealer network. Knows which Fanatics slot — weekly, premier, or buy-now — gets your card the most eyes, and exactly when to pull the trigger.
Paolo
Runs intake, photography, and the white-glove logistics. Your card is tracked, insured, and accounted for from the second it leaves your hands.
Your grail deserves a stage.
Published rates. A real expert in your corner. Limited slots.
Consign With Us →